Thursday, October 19, 2006
CD Review: Johnny Lloyd Rollins’ Let’s Be Poor Together
The album varies as stylistically as any three-year period of Elvis Costello's career, yet feels more naturally cohesive than anything I've heard in the Ipod era.
Let's Be Poor Together MP3s ![Album cover art]()
Earlier today, our staff was giving me hell for saying I "wasn't a Beatles guy." Some even suggested that the hand of God might reach down and flick our tiny office to another plane where we would be forced to listen to nothing but Yoko for eternity.
It's not that I dislike The Beatles -- I intellectually understand their importance in everything that has come after. But they don't hit me where I live. (I have a whole twisted Rolling Stones/Beatles dichotomy that I use to size people up, but that's another story.)
I thought that would make it hard to review Johnny Lloyd Rollins' new disc, Let's Be Poor Together. It's apparently a state offense to spill ink or pixels on the guy without referencing the Fab Four. But, Blair was out of town when the disc hit the office, and Alan had to recuse himself, because he plays sax on the second track, "The Morning After," so the duty fell to me.
Not that I was dreading the review or anything: What I know about Johnny comes via his performances in our offices and on other podcasts on our site. I know the guy's mad-talented, and I love his style. So it wasn't surprising to me that my first cursory spin of the disc was pleasant. By second listen, I was really liking it, but unable to articulate why.
By my third, I was saying "holy shit." Best original disc I've heard all year. Maybe longer. It gets better with every listen.
That's when I realized that the Beatles comparisons are lazy as hell and don't do his songs justice. Johnny may be drawing on McCartney/Lennon (and more heavily on the former), but he's also infusing other varied sounds from Roy Orbison, to gypsy folk, to Cheap Trick, to Chris Issak, to Lindsey Buckingham, to Ben Folds, to Big Star -- all in a distinctive melange. The album varies as stylistically as any three-year period of Elvis Costello's career, yet feels more naturally cohesive than anything I've heard in the Ipod era.
I'm not sayng there isn't any Beatles there -- there certainly is in some of those influences -- but it's Beatlesque in the way that ELO was Beatlesque. If I was really stretching for an elevator speech on this one, I'd call it "The first Traveling Wilburys disc if the Wilburys were wrapped up in one dude instead of all taking turns."
I don't usually do this in a review, but almost every song on this disc is so solid, I want to address each one:
1. "Bedtime for Bonzos": The only extraneous track to me -- it's a 30-second ditty played high-pitched, fast and unintelligible. I generally like cool intros and interludes, but this one feels over-consciously (dare I say) White Album to me. Might have worked at the end of the disc, but leading off it unnecessarily trivializes what's to come.
2. "The Morning After": Johnny announces that he'll "come rockin' like the morning after." He does. It's a ballsy tune, with bluesman lyrics and pop hooks punctuated with sax licks (from TexasGigs' own Alan Cohen). The bridge lines are delivered with an Elvis Costello circa "Radio-Radio" stacatto but with a soulful twang to the voice. The song slows and crescendos nicely leading into a balls-out finale.
3. "Miss Sugar Pie": Roy Orbison in Rockabilly mode, but looser. The rhythm section drives this one.
4. "Sulphur Springs Midnight Scat": I'm hearing gypsy jazz in the verses, in a way that would sound at home on a Squirrel Nut Zippers Album. But the chorus is full and melodic pop. Johnny's scat goes up a couple octaves in a way that few rock musicians can pull off. And when he hits the verse that starts "So tell all my friends in Dixie, forget the rising sun," I get the feeling that Johnny's short time as a Texan has flavored his music.
5. "Blackjack": The McCartney comparison is unavoidable here. Feels like ninties renaissance acoustic McCartney with swelling but subdued drums and loose harmonies. Nice rootsy tune.
6. "Life Back Home": An uptempo acoustic pop number with a harmonica riff. It feels like one of the underappreciated songs from Tom Petty's later albums. This one shows off the thing that gets me again and again on the album -- Johnny changes pace three and four times in the course of a song and it never feels forced. I declare him "master of the bridge."
7. "Bi-Polar Bear Blues": "It's a bummer / when we hit summer." So melancholy, but still makes me smile. Again with the nice bridges. Jeff Lynne would be proud.
8. "Target for Tonight": Ben-Foldsy piano but with a lusty lyric. Nice guitar solos too. Would love to hear this one live. In and out in 2:10 and not a wasted note.
9. "Let's Be Poor Together": My new favorite love song, perhaps because I'm superimposing the journey my wife and I have been on the past couple years. This one tricks you into thinking it is just a nice simple ballad, and then there's the climbing and soaring full-band chorus. I think I'd be disappointed in it solo acoustic having heard it this way. Instrumentally and production-wise there's everything but the kitchen sink in here, including a whistling solo. Good example of how this album is really heavily "produced," but without being overproduced.
10. "For Laura": It's a pop ballad, but with a country backbeat. Doesn't stand out for me like the other tunes, but still nice.
11. "She's Real": A falsetto and a funk kick in the beat make this remind me of Prince's "On the Couch" on the verses. The guitar riff between feels like Jimmy Page. This one jams gently.
12. "Who You Are": This is my favorite tune on the disc, and perhaps is the best metaphor for the whole collection. The lyric is classic without feeling hackneyed. Take the chorus: "Hands were made for clappin / Mouths were made for singing / Money was made for thievin / Better get yours while you can / Life was made for livin' / But time is unforgivin' / A woman was made to love you / But a man don't give a damn." It's buoyed with strong piano and guitar, has the ELO-ish bridge and pulls in strings and horns at the climax. Alan and I debated this song a bit today -- It's hopeful-bluesy enough that it could be Gov't Mule's "Soulshine" (Alan), but it's so earnest and poppy that I could almost hear it in a montage on whatever the kids watch now that Dawson's Creek is no more. In the end, I think Alan's right, which is emblematic of the whole album. Johnny pulls in so many styles and does them so well, that they go right to the edge without being over the top.
13. "One Day at a Time": Ends it all with a nice simple ballad. Just Johnny and a guitar and some rhymes (save for some swelling strings towards the end). "Who You Are" feels more like a finale to me, but that's a minor quibble.
While Johnny's vocals are the heart of the album, its backbone is his able backing band, "The All-Nighters." Eric Swanson's bass; Joey McClellan's lead guitar; and John McIntyre's drums all get their time in the sun and to good effect. I think these songs would mostly be good with just an acoustic guitar, but they wouldn't be as special without the full effect.
Upcoming shows:
- Sunday, Oct. 22, 2006, 8 p.m. at Bend Studio
- Thursday, Dec. 14, 2006, 7 p.m. at Good Records
- Saturday, Dec. 16, 2006, 8 p.m. at Opening Bell Coffee
- Thursday, Jan. 25, 2007, 7 p.m. at ellum: ONSTAGE
- Saturday, March 10, 2007, noon at ellum: ONSTAGE
- Saturday, March 17, 2007, 8 p.m. to 11:30 p.m. at Opening Bell Coffee
- Tuesday, April 10, 2007, 9 p.m. at Barley House
- Thursday, April 26, 2007, 7 p.m. to 10 p.m. at Opening Bell Coffee
- Thursday, May 3, 2007, 9:30 p.m. at Lakewood Bar and Grill
- Friday, May 4, 2007, 10 p.m. at Club Dada (Closed)
- Saturday, May 5, 2007, 9 p.m. at Lone Star Cafe & Club
- Saturday, May 12, 2007, 7:30 p.m. at Lee Harvey's
- Friday, June 22, 2007, 9 p.m. at Lone Star Cafe & Club
- Friday, July 27, 2007, 9 p.m. at Sons of Hermann Hall
- Saturday, Aug. 11, 2007, 6 p.m. at Gezellig (Closed)
- Thursday, Aug. 16, 2007, 10 p.m. at Dan's Silver Leaf
- Friday, Aug. 24, 2007, 9 p.m. at Granada Theater
I'm one of the worst Ipod junkies in the world -- I listen to 10,000 songs on random, and rarely listen to an album straight through anymore. I can't stop playing this one over though -- it sticks together with songs that are lyrically diverse, but all have a solemnly optimistic swagger, if you can imagine such a thing. Listen, and you'll certainly be able to do so.
True, Johnny hearkens back to his influences. Even the brown paper bag packaging and 45-RPM art on the disc itseld cry back to the sixties. But this album feels thoroughly modern and thoroughly original. That's a rare thing these days. I can't wait to hear these tunes in concert. If they can be pulled off this well live, Johnny could go as big as it gets in the post-pop-radio world.
Blair Lovern, says:
I agree with Mike - holy bleepedy bloop!
Staff
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
Mike Orren, says:
Some other takes from out there in internet-land:
Buhdge (Seems to be an earlier EP version): http://www.buhdge.com/hot_buhdge/2006...
Another that seems to be via the Ventura County Reporter: http://www.notlame.com/Johnny_Lloyd_R...
Seems to be popular to compare JLR to Emitt Rhodes, whom I've heard of but haven't heard. Another guy who apparently gets the de rigeur McCartney tag.
Staff
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
Elizabeth Eshelman, says:
Ok #1 - nice on the Chris I. and Big Star references - I don't think many people get those -
#2 - I always would forget the title for "Target for Tonight" and request the "Ben Folds song" - lol and finally,
#3 - I also think "Who you are" is the best song on the album, though each of them are certainly worthy of standing on their own merit.
Ok, and check out Emmitt Rhodes - the guy totally was channeling the same stuff as our Mr. JLR.
Verified
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
Alan Cohen, says:
My favorite is "Who You Are," I think Johnny and the band should end every show with that one
Staff
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
johnnylloydrollins, says:
Thanks for the words.. and not just blowing it off as "beatles".. cus it's not that simple.
one note, yes.. bedtime for bonzo's is meant to be the last track on the album.
you got an early early promo copy which was changed last week with BTFB at the end.. I will send you a new copy..
cheers,
johnny
Anonymous
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
Scott Miller, says:
Very high praise- that Elvis Costello comparison. But (gasp!) "not a Beatles guy"? And here I was thinking I kind of liked you ; )
Verified
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
shampoomohawk, says:
Yeah! Thanks for the 40oz, Liz!
Anonymous
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
Elizabeth Eshelman, says:
anytime, homie. any time.
Verified
3 years, 1 month agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal
chasegassaway, says:
Hey, thats some pretty sexy orchestration.
Eh?
(Wink)
Anonymous
2 years, 11 months agoLink to this comment | Suggest removal