Tuesday, January 23, 2007
Immigration issues should be left to the feds, say activists
Email
|
Print
|
Tell us your story
|
Comments (20)
|
The Farmers Branch City Council met Monday night and approved Ordinance 2903, which repealed Ordinance 2892, banning landlords from renting to illegal immigrants. Ordinance 2900 that called for a citywide election on Ordinance 2892 on May 12 was also repealed.
(A copy of the new ordinance in a word document may be found here.)
State Representative Rafael Anchia flew in from Austin to attend the Council meeting.
“As city council members at the local level, you have a burden,” he told the council members. “A very productive thing for this council to do is to ask the federal government to ask for a comprehensive immigration program at the federal level.”
With the exception of a few outbursts, the meeting remained calm. Many activists, as well as the organization Uniting Farmers Branch, have been stressing peacefulness.
Uniting Farmers Branch is a non-partisan, multiethnic group of residents and business owners who organized in August, 2006, after council member Tim O’Hare attributed all the problems of the City of Farmers Branch to undocumented citizens.
“We realized that we were all of like mind at that City Council meeting and began meeting regularly in order to explore ways to encourage the Farmers Branch City Council not to pass actions that they eventually passed on Nov. 13, 2006,” said Elizabeth Villafranca, a co-chair of Uniting Farmers Branch.
The organization’s mission includes: improving the quality of life of all residents of Farmers Branch; promoting an inclusive vision of participation and leadership in the community of Farmers Branch; promoting respect and dignity of all members of the Farmers Branch community; promoting a positive image of Farmers Branch and seeking to unite, rather than divide.
“We are not pro-illegal immigration,” said Villafranca. “We simply feel that this is not something that the City of Farmers Branch or any other municipality should be involved in.
“Most of us believe that the Federal Government needs to provide comprehensive immigration reform at the earliest moment, which would include a guest worker program and a path to citizenship for many undocumented citizens.”
According to Jim Manning, co-chair for Uniting Farmers Branch, Uniting Farmers Branch has been a very grassroots operation in organizing people concerned about the Farmers Branch City Council. They took a very positive stand in encouraging Farmers Branch not to create legislation against illegal immigrants.
“After Nov. 13, when Farmers Branch City Council approved those ordinances against illegal immigrants, Uniting Farmers Branch tried to find a way to repeal the ordinances,” said Manning.
“We worked with LULAC, ACLU and MELDEF who brought the three lawsuits against the City of Farmers Branch. Bickel & Brewer Storefront, attorneys, sponsored the petition drive to try to find constructive ways to heal the turmoil that had been created in Farmers Branch by the Farmers Branch City Council.”
Carrollton Mayor Becky Miller has advocated all along that cities should let federal officials handle the immigration issue. Mayor Miller, vice president and soon-to-be president of the Metroplex Mayors Association, is urging Dallas area mayors to engage in a letter-writing campaign to federal officials.
“I have decided that we [DFW mayors] will do a letter-writing campaign to the federal officials in an effort to encourage them to keep this as a number one priority,” said Miller.
“We are volunteering to do anything we can as mayor to assist them.”
See more stories in:
Find...
Today
Saviours / Blood of the Sun Oakland, Calif. band Savior worships late 70’s/early 80’s British Heavy Metal, and is said to favor blasphemous diatribes, down-tuned guitars, and cranked-up distortion. Fun shtuff. More info
Blogs
- Before you unsubscribe
Square Pegs - (Neighborhood) joys and sorrows
Square Pegs - Favoriting contest: Billy Joe Shaver at Lee Harvey’s on Saturday
Square Pegs
Latest comments
- Lisa Lawrence Merritt on Video: Sarah Palin protest in Dallas, 10/3/08: Thank God for Checks and Balances built into our country’s governing structure. The issues are to ho...
- Lisa Lawrence Merritt on Bollywood movie review: Drona: It’s amazing how you never see any darker skinned Indian actresses (or actors). Hmmmmm....
- Amy Seslowsky on Downtown Showdown, a Photo Series: Lewisville: I love the veggie photos!...
- Amy Seslowsky on Bollywood movie review: Drona: This sounds like a cult classic. Side note: Bollywood actresses are great looking....
Latest reviews
- Liles on Twisted Root Burger Company: Love this place....
- dallasiphoney on Fox Sports Grill: 

Comments
EdWeirdness Anonymous
I feel that mowing my lawn and washing my car should be left to the Federal Government!
Of course advocates for illegal immigration would assert that such policies are best left to an ineffective, unaccountable bureaucracy that local citizens cannot "un-elect".
Voters of Farmers Branch should demand that these council members step down or initiate a recall election. Better yet, rather than show partisanship or favoritism of any kind, I suggest that any law abiding citizen in Dallas, avoid doing any sort of business with either the city, or the merchants, or the realtors of Farmers Branch, until such time as a council is elected to act in the interest of the citizen and support their views, values and concerns.
1 year, 8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
seewoesa Anonymous
Heh Laura. Me and the Maupins had lunch today and we're looking at your website.
"How's the Cannon?" asked Tom. "By the way, what kind of digital camera are you using?" tmaupin@oklahoman.com
1 year, 8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
fakelord Anonymous
People of the U.S.A. Let it be known that coming into the U.S.A. by illegal means is a FELONY OFFENSE. All illegals should be deported immediately. It is no concern of mine that they come illegaly and have children, uh oh, I guess the kids will have to go too. Too bad for a felony offender. Also, the local police forces everywhere need to step up to the plate and do the job they are paid to do. Illegal immigration is a local problem. They are local, and the INS is like the U.N.-a worthless garbage tax sucking pit. Support the FairTax and the IRS goes away forever and out of yours and mine personal business.
1 year, 8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
fakelord Anonymous
Say NO to any of the BS inthe above article. EdWeirdness has a wonderful comment above. He uses facts, I do to but am much angrier at the problems unfairly imposed on all legal citizens of my country. The greatest that has ever existed in the history of this planet. But unfortunately is methodically being torn to shreds by a confederacy of dunces who have managed to get themselves into a position of power or authority. Grrrrrr.
1 year, 8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Blair Lovern Staff
Illegal entry into the U.S. is a misdemeanor. No one is planning on shipping millions of people anywhere. All this was discussed in Congress a while back.
1 year, 8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Scott Doyle Verified
Not sure if there's been anything on PegNews about the recent announcement, but per this DMN article:
Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials in North Texas will no longer detain most illegal immigrants arrested for Class C misdemeanors, citing a dramatic increase in referrals and limited resources.
10 months, 2 weeks ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
Minnie,
...council member Tim O’Hare attributed all the problems of the City of Farmers Branch to undocumented citizens.
O'Hare attributed all of the problems of Farmers Branch to "undocumented citizens?"
Citation, please.
Also, where did you come with the phrase undocumented citizens." They are not citizens, for Pete's sake! They are here illegally.
*Uniting Farmers Branch is a non-partisan, multiethnic group of residents...."
The organization’s mission includes ... seeking to unite, rather than divide.
...
“We worked with LULAC, ACLU and MELDEF who brought the three lawsuits against the City of Farmers Branch."
If they're seeking to unite, why did they bring 3 lawsuits?
They're "non-partisan" but they've worked with LULAC, ACLU, and MELDEF? I've got some sad news for you, Minnie: those organizations range from left-wing to downright seditionist.
Here's a quote from the founder of MALDEF. It's all over the internet (see http://boards.brownpride.com/showthre... , for example).
Mario Obledo(1998 Presidential Medal of Freedom recipient and former head of Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund—MALDEF) “California is going to be a Mexican state, we are going to control all the institutions. If people don’t like it they should leave.”
Yeah, that's pretty non-partisan, isn't it?
MALDEF and LULAC are both associated with the movement to create a new Mexican state called Aztlan that will consist of every American state from Texas to California (see http://www.sonorannews.com/aztlan.html , for example).
Minnie, I appreciate the fact that Pegasus news is open about the bias of their reporters. However, that doesn't relieve you of the burden to actually report the facts. Part of my duties at work include technical research and writing. If I conveniently left out facts or manipulated the facts like you guys do, I would be out of a job.
Minnie, do your research and report the news. Being a reporter means more than subject-verb agreement. It's fine to say in your article that you disagree with what certain groups or individuals are doing, but it's not okay to leave out things that don't support your spin or to manipulate facts.
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
fakelord:
[EdWeirdness] uses facts, I do to but am much angrier at the problems unfairly imposed on all legal citizens of my country. The greatest that has ever existed in the history of this planet.
Oh, good grief. Your forgot to say that Amerika is stoopid and that George McChimpyBushburton is Hitler.
Have you read what life was like for Jews and many other under Hitler? Do you know that Stalin intentionally starved or otherwise killed millions? Do you know what it's like to be Christian -- or even a regular citizen -- in China? Do you know what life is like for non-Muslims in Muslim countries? Heck, do you know what it's like to be a woman in a Muslim country or a Christian in Sudan? Do you realize that anti-semitism are on the rise everywhere, especially in Europe. Take a trip to Mexico and see what real poverty is.
Yeah, it really is a lot worse here in Amerika than in those places.
Your post is a perfect example of why conservatives consider liberals to be whiny and out of touch with reality.
Life is really good here in the United States. If you lived in China and had made a post critical of the Chinese government, you would be in jail right now.
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Scott Doyle Verified
I'm wondering why this bounced straight from municipal to federal? What happened to the state also having a say in how we handle border-jumpers? Call me conservative, but damn...why outsource the issue to people who aren't in the thick of it and don't have the resources to handle it?
Not that I agree with the Farmers Branch approach, but I'm obviously on board with Irving's. Is anybody in the state legislature 'radical' enough to talk about how we can create resources on our own?
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
Scott Doyle:
I'm wondering why this bounced straight from municipal to federal?
Because the activists know that the federal government is doing little or nothing to combat illegal immigration -- or "undocumented citizens" if you happen to be Minnie.
If the next administration and congress get tough on illegal immigration, then you can bet that the same activists will whine that the feds should butt out and leave it to the states and municipalities to handle "undocumented citizens."
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
Blair Lovern:
Illegal entry into the U.S. is a misdemeanor.
You are correct, and a first-time offense is punishable by a fine ranging from $50 to $250 and up to 6 months in jail. However, the crime is little-enforced and in sanctuary cities like Dallas city employees are not allowed to report illegal aliens -- er, "undocumented citizens" if you're Minnie -- to the federal government. See http://www.ojjpac.org/sanctuary.asp for an informal list of sanctuary cities.
It is illegal for cities to do this because it is in direct violation of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA) passed in 1996 that requires that requires local governments to cooperate with federal official regarding illegal immigration. See http://www.uscis.gov/propub/ProPubVAP... to view the 1996 act.
Of course, you won't see any activists complaining about sanctuary cities and asking that they enforce federal law.
However, it is a felony for someone to re-enter the US after being deported. See http://immigration.findlaw.com/immigr... . Do you care to guess how often that law is enforced?
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
Scott Doyle:
Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials in North Texas will no longer detain most illegal immigrants arrested for Class C misdemeanors, citing a dramatic increase in referrals and limited resources.
Is it any wonder that the activists want to leave enforcement of "undocumented citizens" to the feds?
Thank you, Minnie, for introducing me to the phrase "undocumented citizens." That's the funniest thing I've heard in months.
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Alex Bentley Staff
Mike,
From your comment on the Exxon story: "Sorry, but after your performance in reporting on illegal immigration in Farmers Branch last week, I'm just a little bit suspicious."
Just wanted to point out that the story from "last week" is actually a story from over a year ago.
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Mike Orren Staff
Alex, I think he meant this story from last week:
http://www.pegasusnews.com/news/2008/...
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
Mike Orren:
It was actually this story:
http://www.pegasusnews.com/news/2008/...
Catherine was not being dishonest in her reporting but she did not exactly report the whole story. It's a long, involved process before a lessor would be fined $500.
The link to the ordinance is here:
http://www.supportfarmersbranch.com/O...
Links are good.
I agree that controlling illegal immigration -- "undocumented citizens" per Minnie -- should not be a function of a local government except to the extent required by federal law as I noted (and, ahem, linked to) in another post. However, the federal government is failing to do its job of controlling the borders. If the feds don't do their job, then local government sometimes has to step in and carry the burden.
In fact, according to the Founding Fathers, protecting our borders is one of the few jobs that the federal government is supposed to do. Now they're in our faces about everything but enforcing the borders.
By the way, I was in a class at a church in Farmers Branch last Sunday afternoon because my wife is godmother to her nephew who is taking CCD there. The class is 75% non-English speaking and I would bet my next paycheck that most of them are illegal.
I was thinking about the flurry of posting this time last week and still stand by my opinion on how to address the problem: (1) close the borders; (2) once the borders are closed, provide a reasonable path to citizenship.
The nun, who was born in Mexico, told our class before Christmas that, if they want to live in America, they need to learn English and integrate with other Americans. I've never heard so much groaning in my life. I compared their response with that of the Vietnamese refugees who flooded my high school in the late 70s and the two who became the valedictorian and salutatorian of our graduating class despite not knowing a word of English when they stepped off the boat a few years earlier. Different cultures.
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
jtmbls Anonymous
Does anyone remember the refugees (I think they were from Cuba, I’m not certain.) several years ago who made a boat from the body of a vintage American pick-up truck? They made it to within just a few miles of our shores before they were picked up by the coast guard. I think if you do something extraordinarily creative like that you should just get waved in. In fact, I smell a reality TV show…
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
CastleHills Anonymous
Michael says,
...."The class is 75% non-English speaking and I would bet my next paycheck that most of them are illegal."
Wow. Michael, I'm feel so bad for you and the world you live in, where non-English=bad=illegal.
...."Do you know what it's like to be Christian -- or even a regular citizen -- in China? Do you know what life is like for non-Muslims in Muslim countries?"
It's probably a lot like being a woman in your household.
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
CastleHills
Wow. Michael, I'm feel so bad for you and the world you live in, where non-English=bad=illegal.
I never said that not speaking English should be illegal. However, I don't see how you can possibly argue the point that refusing to learn English when you come to America won't keep people from reaching their full potential.
I taught ESL classes for years -- mostly to illegal aliens. It wasn't always easy for them, but they knew that if they wanted a better life, they would have to learn English. Strangely enough, the classes were about 75% female. The women recognized that learning English would benefit them. The husbands didn't want to be bothered.
I got hammered on this last week, but when my company sent me to live in the Laurentian mountains north of Montreal for about half a year, I took the effort to learn Quebecois? Why? Because I knew that I would be hindered in a French-speaking (if you can call Quebecois French) if I couldn't converse with the the people that I needed to talk to.
My wife is of Hispanic descent, and though the most recent immigrant in her family tree was a grandfather who came here as a baby, she did not learn to speak English until she started school. She was lost and humiliated. Is that what you want for immigrant children to feel when they're thrust into an English-speaking society?
Liberals like to position themselves as standing up for the oppressed. However, telling Hispanics that they don't have to learn English is very, very cruel.
It's probably a lot like being a woman in your household.
My wife would find your statement very, very funny.
-Mike
8 months, 1 week ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
jtmbls Anonymous
Mike - Just out of curiosity, how did your wife feel about the comparison you made earlier about the difference between the Hispanic and Vietnamese cultures, her being of Hispanic discent and all?
8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Michael McCullough Verified
jtmbls,
Mike - Just out of curiosity, how did your wife feel about the comparison you made earlier about the difference between the Hispanic and Vietnamese cultures, her being of Hispanic discent and all?
She is far, far more critical than I am. Her family moved to Farmers Branch around 1960 and were the first Hispanics in their neighborhood. Her parents spoke English fluently yet only spoke Spanish at home.
My wife did not know a word of English when she started first grade. She had to endure the ridicule of children and teachers alike for not being able to speak English. Her parents wouldn't help her with homework and lied about her age to put her to work in a sewing factory at age 13.
My wife vowed to be a different kind of parent, and she is. Her daughter refused Hispanic-only scholarships to college because she considers race-based scholarships to be, well, racist. I'm proud of her.
I fume when those defending illegal immigration say that "illegal immigrants do the jobs that Americans don't want to do." It is perilously close to the arguments made for defending slavery.
I want something better for people who come to the United States. Our current policy of not encouraging them to learn English guarantees that they will be limited to the most menial of jobs.
Those on the left will say that the comparison I made (and that my wife makes, too) is racist. It's not -- it's reality. There is an SAT-learning center just off of I-75 near Beltline. It's on the northeastern edge of a predominantly Hispanic neighborhood yet the sign is in English -- and Chinese. It makes me sad.
8 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Post a comment
(Requires free PegasusNews.com account.)