Sunday, March 11, 2007
UPDATED: Dallas high school student sent to Haskell jail for being undocumented
Updated 10:58 a.m., March 13, 2007
Email
|
Print
|
Tell us your story
|
Comments (10)
|
My friend Monica is 18-years-old.
She has lived in Dallas with her family since she was 5-years-old.
She is an honor student at a Dallas public high school where she is (was) set to graduate in about two months. She has made plans for college after graduation this spring.
Larry James' Urban Daily
A repository of ideas, resources, commentary and opinions concerning the issues facing low-income residents of the inner cities of the United States and how mainstream America largely forgets or, worse, ignores the day-to-day realities of urban life for the so-called "poor." Written and edited by the President & CEO of Central Dallas Ministries. Please visit CDM.
She is a great example of the success and accomplishment of one inner city child who grew up in a very poor, but loving family here in inner city Dallas, Texas.
In so many ways she reminds me of my own daughters.
It is very possible that last Friday Monica's life took a drastic turn in a very different direction, a turn from which she may never recover.
Friday was "Senior Skip Day" at her school. Most of the senior class didn't attend classes.
A friend hosted a party for friends at a ranch in Greenville, Texas.
For some reason, the details are still unclear to me, the Greenville Police Department showed up at the party. Every student present who had valid identification was released and was free to go. Those students who had no identification were taken into custody.
Monica and two friends--one a cousin--were transferred to an immigration center here in Dallas. They were booked into the center too late in the day to allow anyone to make bail. As a result, they had to spend the night there.
Then, for some reason we don't understand, on Saturday morning, immigration officials transferred Monica and her friends to the Rolling Plains Regional Jail in Haskell, Texas just north of Abilene, almost 200 miles away from home. There Monica awaits some sort of hearing, though she does not know when it will be.
Got the picture?
A sweet, smart, naive, model high school student being held in a West Texas jail for being "undocumented." Even though she has been here for over a decade, and even though she, nor any other member of her family, has ever had issues with any authority in Dallas, she is now in jail.
The reason?
Current U. S. immigration policy is being driven by the decisions and the discretion of local municipalities. Federal immigration officials do not sweep public schools to pick up undocumented students. Nor do they insist that public schools deny these students entry. Federal immigration officials leave families alone for the most part, unless they encounter criminal behavior.
Sadly, towns like Farmers Branch and Greenville are taking a different approach. Kids like Monica pay the price.
I spent most of the day on the phone on Saturday trying to reach elected officials who might intervene for her. These efforts will continue. So far, I have been unable to accomplish anything real for her.
So, this morning my young friend finds herself in jail 200 miles from her mother and father and family. She is scared. She is alone. I pray she is not in danger.
Immigration provides lots of issues and material for abstract debate these days.
Monica moves the debate onto completely new ground, don't you think?
She is my friend. Her mom and dad are my friends. What she is going through is wrong. This is much more than a debate.
UPDATE:
A brief update on our friend, Monica.
After events last Friday (see my post on Sunday, March 11, 2007), Monica and her first cousin, Jose, spent the weekend locked up in the Rolling Plains Regional Jail located in Haskell, Texas, north of Abilene, about 200 miles from her home here in Dallas.
Her parents and family have been frantic, to say the very least. All of us who know and love her and her parents joined them in a long, tough weekend.
Monday morning, thanks to an extremely generous donor and friend of CDM and this family, Monica and Jose were bonded out of the detention center.
If I reported the cost of the bond, you would be shocked. Two very fine high school seniors, far from criminals in any sense of the word, were forced to come up with an outlandish amount of money to secure their release while they await a hearing before an immigration judge.
After paying the bond in Dallas at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE--formerly Immigration and Naturalization Services), the same donor drove to Haskell and brought the two young people home on Monday evening.
So, last night rather late, we enjoyed a "reunion party" at the home of one of our CDM team members and her family who lives here in the neighborhood.
It was an amazing evening.
The love that flowed between the two families of these two wonderful young people touched me deeply. Lots of tears. Monica's father and Jose's father are twin brothers. The connection among all of the members of these two families is amazing to watch.
It was a powerful time, as all of us who are friends observed the tearful, j0yous reunion. And naturally, we enjoyed our share of hugs and tears and laughter all around as well!
When the initial welcoming was complete, we joined hands in a circle and we prayed a prayer of thanksgiving and we asked the Lord to bless Monica and Jose and their families. We prayed for an end to the current immigration insanity in our nation and our state. We asked God for a just, fair and equitable solution to our national hesitancy. We stood in solidarity, community and oneness, as an extended family. The fact that we were black, brown and white didn't matter to anyone. The fact that some of us spoke Spanish and some English and some both didn't matter either. We were all grateful to be together. We were proud to call each other "friend" and "amigo."
Afterwards, we all enjoyed a great meal and lots of fellowship.
It was a night I know I will never forget.
I'll have more to report in the days ahead. For now please know how much Monica, Jose and their family appreciate your concern.
I have a feeling that the story and experience of these two great teenagers may make a difference in the struggle to see a just plan for immigration reform enacted.
Things are not right in this nation today.
Pegasus News content partner - Larry James Urban Daily
See more stories in:
Find...
Today
Sullivan's Steakhouse dinner & fireworks They say fireworks can be seen from the third story of the parking garage, which doesn't sound too glamorous, but we bet it somehow still is. Or, start your own fireworks with their "summer of $69" menu. More info
Blogs
- It’s me, not the phone
Square Pegs - Local musicians make a song for Neda
Square Pegs - St. Vincent on Letterman
Square Pegs
Latest comments
- Pavel Lishin on Pegasus News content partner Shawn Williams caught in Monday's Dallas County police chase: If you’ve got a helicopter, there’s no reason to be zooming around in cars. Sure, several squad cars...
- Tracy Yost on Allen boy's butt allegedly burned by bad teacher: ditto what Pavel said....
- Tracy Yost on What Dallas-Fort Worth chefs and restaurateurs will be cooking at home on Fourth of July: I’m cooking jambalya tomorrow, pecan smoked sausage, shrimp, extra hot! (yes I *know* I’m not a chef...
- Pavel Lishin on Allen boy's butt allegedly burned by bad teacher: For the record, polygraphs are utter crap regardless of outcome....
Latest reviews
- caitlynbuckley on Jake's Old Fashioned Hamburgers (Dallas / Skillman & Abrams): If you are craving a delicious, greasy hamburger and you want it immediately, Jake’s is a great plac...
- John Meyer on Tony's Pizza & Pasta (Dallas): If it weren’t for Tony’s, I’d have no place left to go for a quick and tasty Italian meal around my ...
- Neff Conner on Angry Dog: i and five others went for lunch at 11:15 on a Friday to get our burgers on. We couldn’t help but co...
Things you can't miss
Latest stories
- Theater review: The Man with the Pointed Toes
- Pegasus News content partner Shawn Williams caught in Monday's Dallas County police chase
- Fort Worth mayor wants feds to look into Rainbow Lounge raid
- Body of slain taxi driver found in rural Denton County
- Dallas-based Queer Liberaction to hold "Milk Box" community forums in Fort Worth

Comments
terryorze Anonymous
I don't want to be mean, but breaking the law for ten years does not make it better. Her family needs to go to Mexico to take care of thier daughter when she gets deported. She has a lot to learn about living in her country, and she will need help learning to cope with life in her country. It is unfortunate that she has to leave her friends and the life she knows.
I do not hate; indeed, I am in the process of trying to immigrate legally to Panama. I know that it is not easy.
2 years, 3 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Alan Cohen Staff
Terryorze -
What kind of standard is it to arrest people for not having identification? That is lunacy. So if someone can't afford a car and chooses not to go through the process of getting a driver's license, they automatically become a target for arrest based on that alone? Are we to assume that everyone without a drivers license is here illegally? If so, lets have police start raiding the all the buses around the metroplex. Is it not worth giving Monica the chance to defend herself before we send her to a jail hundreds of miles from her family and home? What were the charges she would be defending herself against anyhow? Perhaps partying without picture ID is a crime in Greenville, but I doubt it. It is more likely overzealous "ends justify the means" immigration policy.
I don't think there is enough information from Larry's article to absolutely assume that Monica is in the United States illegally. But even if she is, I think the scenario Larry describes goes far beyond a "should we deport illegal immigrants" issue.
I wish Monica the best. I hope her nightmare ends soon.
2 years, 3 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
terryorze Anonymous
You are correct, the article does not say that she is in the country illegally. The article does say that everybody they could identify was released. Since no US police department enforces immigration laws, I think that it is reasonable to believe that the teenaged adults were doing something else illegal. You cannot give a ticket to an unknown person, so you have to take them into custody until they can be identified. Otherwise, anybody that wanted to avoid prosecution from any minor violation could just leave thier identification at home, and be immune from prosecution.
2 years, 3 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Alan Cohen Staff
You make a good point, but even if I agree 100% with your last argument, it still makes no sense to send Monica hundreds of miles away from her family and home for an offense that would normally result in a simple ticket if she had i.d.?
But the truth is that I have trouble buying 100% of your argument. What happens if someone leaves their drivers license at home and gets caught jaywalking? They go to jail? They get shipped off hundreds of miles away before they have a chance to go back home and get their i.d.? I've had friends pulled over and ticketed for driving without a license and they did not go to jail. They did get a big ticket and were forced to park their car until a licensed driver showed up. So I have to believe that jail is not the only option when i.d. is not immediately available.
However, I will say that my first comment was made with the assumption that kids were released from the party without penalty if they had i.d., but I suppose tickets would also be plausible so I can't make that assumption with certainty.
2 years, 3 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
gpadilla Anonymous
This is nothing new. I see cases like this at least 3 a week .I work at a law firm that handels alot of immigration matters. I understand how she came to be detained. Its sad to say but this is becoming all to comman.We should go ahead and remove the STATUE OF LIBERTY ,because it stands for nothing these days. Oh and the OATH OF ALLEGIANCE well today most AMERICANS don't know it's meaning much less the words. America becomes stronger when ALL of its citizens respect the different opinions,cultures, ethinic groups,and religions found in this country.That is what this contry was built on.The only true AMERICANS are native indians.
2 years ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
SonyaBlade Anonymous
Every illegal alien should know to purchase fake documentation once entering the country, it's only common sense.
2 years ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
J_Mortimer Anonymous
If the borders were not so open where anyone can cross, then there wouldn't be the presumption that someone like her was an illegal alien.
What people like Mr. James don't seem to realize is that if there was tighter control on our borders and a tight programs for guest workers and others legally entering the country, then people like her would be far less likely to go through what she went through. Her case is not an argument against tighter immigration control but an argument for it.
J
2 years ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
David Gouldin Verified
"This is nothing new. I see cases like this at least 3 a week .I work at a law firm that handles a lot of immigration matters. I understand how she came to be detained. It's sad to say but this is becoming all to common.We should go ahead and remove the STATUE OF LIBERTY ,because it stands for nothing these days. Oh and the OATH OF ALLEGIANCE well today most AMERICANS don't know its meaning much less the words. America becomes stronger when ALL of its citizens respect the different opinions,cultures, ethnic groups,and religions found in this country.That is what this country was built on.The only true AMERICANS are native indians."
... you work for which law firm?
2 years ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
terryorze Anonymous
Well, I went home with the waitress The way I always do How was I to know She was with the Russians, too
I was gambling in Havana I took a little risk Send lawyers, guns and money Dad, get me out of this
I'm the innocent bystander Somehow I got stuck Between the rock and the hard place And I'm down on my luck And I'm down on my luck And I'm down on my luck
Now I'm hiding in Honduras I'm a desperate man Send lawyers, guns and money The <italics>poop </italics>(censored) has hit the fan
Some laws are bad, but we have follow them any way. Believe me me I want this stupid law changed, but I guarantee you the law is not so clear in her home country if it is Latin American. Nevertheless I want to go live in her country or Panama as soon as I can get through the immigration maze. It is very hard to get residency in Latin America. The land and the people are beautiful. Oh and I am a native american indian at least by the definition of Indians. If my mother is an Indian, I am full blood indian. By white mans treaties I am half.
Via Con Dios.
1 year, 11 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Stanley Anonymous
Larry works with the working poor. If there weren't 20,000,000 illegal immigrants here, wages would be higher and there would be fewer of the working poor.
1 year, 7 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Post a comment