Jump to: site navigation, content.

Monday, August 25, 2008

Fighting crime in Texas should include investing in kids

By Scott Henson of Grits For Breakfast

Email Print Tell us your story Comments (9)

As Texas kids head back to school today, it's worth raising the question of whether too much public debate is focused on crime and punishment and too little on investments in education and mental health care that might prevent more incarceration.

That's the gist of the "Fight Crime: Invest in Kids" initiative proposed recently by a national coalition of police, prosecutors and crime victims. I agree with Doc Berman that education and crime are too seldom linked in the public discourse. That's not just a "framing strategy," as Dan Filler put it, it's a valid interpretation of the data that's become unpopular in recent years because of political arguments labeling its proponents "liberal" or "soft on crime." However, that doesn't invalidate the stance or reduce its import to mere clever political posturing. From the group's press release:

Research shows that high school dropouts are three and a half times more likely than graduates to be arrested and eight times more likely to be incarcerated. Nineteen of the top 25 largest U.S. cities have school districts where 40 percent or more of students do not graduate on time. Nearly 70 percent of all inmates in our nation's prisons failed to earn a high school diploma.



The law enforcement leaders are members of Fight Crime: Invest in Kids, a national anti-crime organization made up of over 4,000 police chiefs, sheriffs, district attorneys, and violence survivors. They called on Congress and state lawmakers to expand pre-kindergarten, one of the most effective strategies to increase graduation rates.



"If kids get strong start early in life, we can cut our dropout rate and improve our communities," Lynch said. "To help more kids get that strong start, we need to fund early childhood education programs and ensure that every child that qualifies is able to enroll."



The Fight Crime: Invest in Kids members released a report called "School or the Streets," showing that increasing graduation rates by 10 percentage points will prevent 3,000 murders and 175,000 aggravated assaults in America every year.

To the extent those estimates are accurate, failures by Texas public schools on a massive scale contribute mightily to the expanding prison population.

In May, former Secretary of State Colin Powell's organization, America's Promise, issued these data regarding dropout rates in the largest Texas cities:

Dallas: 44.4%

Houston: 54.6%

San Antonio: 51.9%

Austin: 58.2%

Fort Worth: 55.5%

As Grits argued in reaction to that analysis, there are particular subgroups among dropouts who account for a disproportionate amount of crime and public safety resources:

Straight-up illiteracy is a key criminogenic factor. It's long been known, for example, that while dyslexics make up about 10% of students, they make up 30% or more of those in prison.



As far as reducing crime, an even more important subcategory are kids with incarcerated parents, who tend to be 6-8 times more likely than their peers to wind up incarcerated themselves. Making sure those kids stay in school and have real opportunities to succeed might be the single most important contribution society could make to reducing future crime.

Texas' massive prison system shows it does a good job of holding its citizens accountable (one in 21 adult Texans are in prison, in jail, on probation or on parole), but these high dropout rates show there's been little progress made holding schools accountable for their frankly lousy outcomes.

I spend a lot of time on this blog looking at the back end of the system's failures and how we manage those who've already violated societal rules. But there's little question reducing those massive dropout rates would reduce crime and systemic pressure on the front end better than anything that could be done after people have already offended. Worth contemplating, certainly, as everybody heads back to school.


Pegasus News content partner - Grits For Breakfast

See more stories in:

Comments

Scott Miller

Scott Miller Verified

Seems to me that investing public funds in early childhood education wouldn't see any real results for too many election cycles.

So I can't see where the idea stands a chance. Nothing in this country is done politically for the long term. Not anymore, anyway.

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Scott Doyle

Scott Doyle Verified

Seems about as effective as throwing said investment towards abortions of unwanted chilluns.

Maybe that's too PuC to write about?

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Pavel Lishin

Pavel Lishin Verified

Nah, you see the results of an abortion right away. You just usually don't want to, because it's kinda gross.

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

fratermus Anonymous

If we assume "dropouts" == "failures by Texas public schools" then we are doomed to failure.

It's a function of dysfunctional culture. A pre-K program might be able to counteract some counterproductive cultural training but it does not follow that public schools are the source of the problem.

Onlookers: for a more serious discussion about the effect of legalized abortion on crime rates google "freakonomics crime". It's a difficult and interesting viewpoint.

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Scott Doyle

Scott Doyle Verified

Well, you're neurons simply ain't firin' right if you can't pass in Dallas schools these days.

And I'm not saying abortion is the answer, I'm simply of the mind that you can't educate those unwilling to learn.

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Scott Doyle

Scott Doyle Verified

Ack, your*.

Mornings are not Doyle's strong suit. :(

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Jason Rice

Jason Rice Verified

:: Onlookers: for a more serious discussion about the effect of legalized abortion on crime rates google "freakonomics crime". It's a difficult and interesting viewpoint.

And much to my embarrassment a while back - a statistically disprovable one - so don't go bonkers on that apparent correlation unless you need more humility in your day ;o)

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Pavel Lishin

Pavel Lishin Verified

For the record, I am saying that abortion is the answer. To pretty much any questions you might have.

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Jason Rice

Jason Rice Verified

Pavel, Back to that "people" argument, eh?

1 year, 2 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )

Post a comment

(Requires free PegasusNews.com account.)


(Forgotten your password?)

:

:

Find...

an event a Pegasus Pick
a restaurant a garage sale
a drink special a movie showtime
local music an organization
a job a political contribution
a house a deal
a pet photos

Add...

an event a garage sale
a lost pet a band
a story a photo

Today

Fall 2009 Dinner With Dialogue Series Eating "sustainably" -- without harming animals, farm workers, or the environment -- will be the topic at this dinner at Celebration restaurant, with author Pamela Walker plus Michael and Debby Sams of Full Quiver Farms from Kemp, Texas. More info

Blogs

See more

Latest comments

See more recent comments

Latest reviews

  • jognmcdermott on India West Fine Dining & Lounge: This place has it all good food sweet service. I proposed to my fiance here it was perfect! we loved...
  • Billusa99 on Pappas Bros. Steak House: Agent 99 and I had dinner here last week for our anniversary and it was stellar! The somm. we had re...
  • Colby Walton on El Taco H (Grapevine): Tried this Grapevine strip center taqueria for the first time tonight, after seeing it mentioned in ...

See more recent reviews


Quantcast