Jump to: site navigation, content.

Local stuff that matters to you.
Did you know about Buster Brown Bandplaying at brooklyn Jazz Cafe today?
News & events for
Saturday, December
5

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Texas Education Board to consider equalizing credit for high school student-athletes

On Friday, the Texas State Board of Education (SBOE) will consider action to equalize credits for student-athletes under the state's new 4x4 graduation plan.

The 4x4 curriculum, adopted in November 2006, requires that students complete four years each of science and math, upping the total number of credits to graduate from 24 to 26. Despite other changes, requirements for student-athletes were not altered. Texas high schoolers choosing to participate in four years of sports have long received only two physical education credits.

However, when 24 credits were required for graduation, there was wiggle room for athletes to participate non-credited for two years (junior and senior years) and still graduate under any of the three graduation programs: minimum, recommended, and distinguished achievement. Now, extra room for uncredited electives is gone and student-athletes may be forced to decide between distinguished graduation and participation in their sport.

According to the Texas High School Coaches Association (THSCA) and many parents, this is unfair to student-athletes. "It's a matter of equality," says D.W. Rutledge, THSCA Executive Director. "Athletics is the only elective affected this way."

As Rutledge points out, while athletes receive only the two credits for four years of participation, similar electives, such as dance, marching band, and ROTC, all receive four credits.

After realizing the discrepancy when helping his eighth-grade son sign up for high school courses, Craig Agnew, an assistant coach at Brenham High School, drafted a petition asking that athletics become an up-to-four credit elective. In March 2008, the SBOE approved the petition, 13 to 2, and decided to move ahead with the rule-making process, going against the Commissioner of Education's recommendation.

Beginning with discussion in May, the Board later distributed surveys to school district administrators asking for feedback on the potential provision. According to the TEA website, most administrators were in favor of "additional flexibility in the graduation plans." The Board intended to take action on the item in September, but Hurricane Ike postponed the meeting to November, whence the Board decided to again postpone action until later this week.

"There's been favorable reaction from several of the board members," says Rutledge, who is hopeful about Friday's decision. "The main thing we want to stress is that it won't take away from any academic rigor that's been placed in the new graduation plan."

On January 23 the SBOE will consider five options for awarding athletic credit:

1) allow students to earn four credits toward graduation for athletics, but the final two credits would have to be earned for the extracurricular activity offered outside the regular school day;

2) expand the number of Physical Education (PE) credits allowed toward graduation to four;

3) allow districts to submit an innovative course application for the third and fourth credits of athletics;

4) establish Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills for athletics courses;

5) maintain the current two equivalency credits for athletics.

(tea.state.tx.us)



  • Staff
  • Verified User
  • Anonymous

Jason Rice, says:

Anybody know if the musicians (ya know, band geeks) have the same beef?

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Erin Rice, says:

Jason, I actually covered that above. Students in the marching band already receive four credits for four years of participation.

Is that what you were referring to?

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

monogodo, says:

When did athletics switch from being extracurricular to being an elective?

It seems to me that if any athletic program cuts players from the team, it should extracurricular. If anyone who signs up gets to participate, then I'm fine with it being an elective.

Anonymous

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

momzilla, says:

Not sure when it changed in Texas, but back in the dark ages when I was in high school, athletics was a PE credit. At that time we were usually required to have 3.5 credits PE. (Plus one semester of school nurse demonstrating condoms on a banana, showing nasty pictures of people with their faces eaten by syphilis, and talking about the "crutches" of alcohol and drugs, aka health class.)

Anonymous

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Lisa Lawrence Merritt, says:

Band counts (or did) as a PE credit.

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Pavel Lishin, says:

momzilla: Man, you got to see rotten-out faces? Our pictures went a little further south.

LLM: I think that's only true of marching band. Sitting and blowing/strumming/banging doesn't really count, I don't think.

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

jtmbls, says:

That all depends on how hard you blow Pavel.

Anonymous

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Jason Rice, says:

Erin - yes, that was my question. I remember getting wrapped around the PE spokes my senior year... yep, I had to suit up in those attractive orange shorts and shower with thugs just to graduate because "music" and "PE" were only interchangeable IF you finished out the concert season as well. (Smart) Don't know why that wasn't obvious to me o first read. Probably a phobic reaction.

Note to seniors: don't get kicked out right after marching contest. You can live without the jacket but the showers scar you for life.

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Jason Rice, says:

Pavel, it also depends on other physical exertion factors

hmm

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Pavel Lishin, says:

This is what I get for posting in the morning. I didn't even think about it. :(

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

John McClelland, says:

If most schools are, or want to switch to, the block semester system, wouldn't getting 26 credits be fairly easy?

We didn't have the block semester system when I was in high school in NC, but I know they have switched to it since then.

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

Erin Rice, says:

John, here is a piece from one of the legislative alerts sent by the THSCA. It indicates that block scheduling actually makes it more difficult for student-athletes who participate uncredited for two years:

"Coach Agnew said that the problem became clear to him last year as he was helping his eighth-grade son determine what would be needed to complete the Distinguished Graduation Plan in high school. Craig added that his son’s problem is further exacerbated by the nature of the block scheduling system used in his district’s high school, which schedules two back-to-back block schedule class periods per subject. This leaves little time for courses that do not provide graduation credits."

Verified

10 months, 2 weeks ago
Link to this comment | Suggest removal

What do you think?

:

:

Email Print 12 Comments Contribute

See more stories in:


Quantcast