Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Oncor wants electricity customers to pay $93 million for smart meters they’ll never use
Email
|
Print
|
Tell us your story
|
Comments (4)
|
The Oncor electricity delivery company wants its residential customers to pay $93 million for obsolete “smart meters” the company ordered but customers will now never use because they’re not up to state regulations.
The issue is part of a pending Oncor rate increase which, if approved by the Public Utilities Commission later this year, will increase the average customers’ bill by over five dollars.
In January the company already began charging customers an extra $2.21 per month to pay for new meters that do comply with state regulations - regardless of whether or not they have received a new meter.
The surcharge, which will be collected for 11 years, applies whether or not Oncor customers have received a new meter. The rollout won’t be completed for three years.
Any increase would mark the second time this year that Oncor customers had been told to pay for advanced meters.
The proposal to recover costs for the obsolete meters is a focal point for opponents of the rate hike–among them consumer groups, a coalition of cities and the PUC legal staff.
“These costs should be borne by Oncor, not by ratepayers,” PUC staff attorney Patrick Peters III asserted in a rate case filing.
In an advisory ruling issued last week, two administrative law judges ruled that Oncor is only entitled to part of the amount because its meter purchases were “imprudent,” purchased prematurely and so customers shouldn’t have to foot the whole bill.
Nearly 900,000 smart meters were bought before the Texas Public Utilities Commission issued operating standards, and officials say the meters are not in compliance.
On the other hand, the company thinks their customers should pay for the meters since the equipment was designed to help reduce utility costs for consumers.
All of the smart meters are currently in use and will be replaced with new meters that are in compliance if the cost of those meters can be recovered, said Oncor spokesperson Catherine Cuellar.
The first-generation smart meters will then be reallocated and used for other projects, such as city street lights, where meters do not require the same customer functionality.
Cuellar added that the original meters were bought at the request of the state and that in order to fund the second-generation meters, the company needs to recover the cost of the first-generation meters as well. If that cost cannot be recovered, Cuellar said the original first-generation smart meters will continue to be used by customers at their residences.
“If we didn’t feel as though they were a prudent investment,” company spokesman Chris Schein said, “we would not have sought recovery.”

Pegasus News content partner - TheRockwallNews.com
See more stories in:
Find...
Latest Outbursts
- Today, the first ever **Restaurant Rivalries: Paint Ball Wars** was held at GatSplat in Lewisville. Local favorite restaurant staff, food & beverage supplier...
- If you aren't willing to give your land away for free, the Irving City Council thinks you're a big meanie and will whine about you in the press.
- Romanian Festival in Colleyville
- Jack Ruby's hat sold for $53,775
Today
Fall 2009 Dinner With Dialogue Series Eating "sustainably" -- without harming animals, farm workers, or the environment -- will be the topic at this dinner at Celebration restaurant, with author Pamela Walker plus Michael and Debby Sams of Full Quiver Farms from Kemp, Texas. More info
Latest comments
- bobmoz on Dallas Videofest 2009 - 72 Musicians: Hi Teresa. Thanks for writing about my film. I’m sorry you didn’t like it. At the risk of sounding l...
- BillBigD on Ocean Prime on Cedar Springs in Dallas to open November 12: I been to this place in Miami and the food is quite good. But they better get a clue on Happy Hour i...
- BillBigD on Chef Kenny Mills leaves Sullivan's for new steakhouse in downtown Dallas: I aslo like both of Mike’s places. Goodluck to him downtown...
- Donna Chen on Ethics of Food panel stirs it up on Friday at Dallas Institute of Humanities: I felt briefly guilty about ordering the short rib sandwich right after the discussion, but then I t...
Latest reviews
- jognmcdermott on India West Fine Dining & Lounge: This place has it all good food sweet service. I proposed to my fiance here it was perfect! we loved...
- Billusa99 on Pappas Bros. Steak House: Agent 99 and I had dinner here last week for our anniversary and it was stellar! The somm. we had re...
- Colby Walton on El Taco H (Grapevine): Tried this Grapevine strip center taqueria for the first time tonight, after seeing it mentioned in ...
Things you can't miss
Latest stories
- Michael Schneider plays Brahms' Piano Concerto with Lewisville Lake Symphony
- Concert preview: Mastodon and Deathlok at the House of Blues (November 11)
- Sampling food, drink, and culture at annual Romanian Food Festival in Colleyville
- Photo gallery: AIA Dallas Tour of Homes
- Ethics of Food panel stirs it up on Friday at Dallas Institute of Humanities

Comments
Oudekerk Anonymous
"Cuellar added that the original meters were bought at the request of the state and that in order to fund the second-generation meters, the company needs to recover the cost of the first-generation meters as well. If that cost cannot be recovered, Cuellar said the original first-generation smart meters will continue to be used by customers at their residences.
“'If we didn’t feel as though they were a prudent investment,” company spokesman Chris Schein said, 'we would not have sought recovery.'”
Why isn't the State paying for them, rather than ratepayers, who are now paying for the "approved" version?
Schein apparently went to a business school where the laws of physics were suspended.
5 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Catherine Cuellar Verified
In Saturday's Dallas Morning News, the paper ran a correction to this story stating Oncor's first generation automated meters are currently in use and will continue to be used for streetlights and other functions where consumer functionality of the newer advanced digital meters isn't needed.
5 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
David Goodspeed Verified
and even though my power is still out due to the storm I bet I still have to pay my 2 bucks this month ... not to mention the double-billing last month (grumble, grumble)
5 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Pavel Lishin Verified
So, is Oncor a provider, or do they just control how the electricity comes to your home? Basically, can you just switch to (shameless plug) Green Mountain and avoid the whole surcharge, as well as indirectly showing 'em who's boss?
5 months ago ( Link to this comment | Suggest removal )
Post a comment