Similar
Stories
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
Padma Lakshmi denies stereotypes in Top Chef Texas
Season 9 opts to cover the entire state with a broad stroke of the brush.
Top Chef: Texas debuts on November 2, and as Bravo describes it, it's "bigger in Texas." Texas overall, that is. Dallas, Houston, or Fort Worth aren't important as individual cities.
Co-host Padma Lakshmi tried to defend the upcoming season's transformation of Texas into a giant hee-haw rodeo on a media conference call on Tuesday, but ended up reinforcing the stereotypical thinking on the part of the producers. If you haven't seen the trailer yet (below), it's a parade of cowboy hats, bales of hay, and denim, like the denim dress Lakshmi wears.
Where previous seasons focused on a single city, Season 9 focuses on Texas as a whole. So why not a show placed in a single Texas city such as Houston or Dallas?
"We have to outdo ourselves every season, I don't know why you have to make this negative," Lakshmi said. "We don't think of it as stereotyping, we think of it as bigger than ever. I live in New York but I can't think of the last time I visited the Statue of Liberty. But of course the show is going to go to Ellis Island."
What were some of the stereotypes broken or upheld during the filming, asked Addie Broyles of the Austin American-Statesman.
"I didn't have any stereotypes in my mind," Lakshmi said. "The portions are bigger in Texas. The serving sizes are larger. If you're writing about our time in Austin, it's a great little town. Well, it's not even really that little. It's different from the rest of Texas."
But it sounded like Padma and company weren't able to gather much intelligence about the rest of Texas. Her impression of San Antonio seemed limited to a sashay down the Riverwalk, and she had nothing to say about Dallas-Fort Worth at all.
"I wish I had had more time to explore the city," she said about San Antonio. "... The unfortunate part is that we're working a lot, so it's kindof hard to get the flavor of a city in such a short time."
She reiterated the importance of showcasing Texas rather than cities within Texas. "... We're not there so much to highlight the city as we are to highlight the chefs in that city. But this season does have the traditional barbecue challenges -- you do see the things you expect to see that people do attach to Texas."
How will the show change the perception that Texas is all about beef & BBQ, asked a reporter from the San Antonio Express News. "I don't know if we played into it," Lakshmi said. "There is a challenge where we talk about ribs. Some things couldn't be avoided. There are some contestants from Texas -- they do more to dispel that notion than anything we did."
The contestants from Texas are Andrew Curren and Paul Qui from Austin.
The San Antonio Current has the right idea:
"I'll be playing my own Top Chef drinking game, taking a sip whenever anyone conspicuously dons an oversized cowboy hat, says something is 'bigger in Texas,' or finds another way to offend locals with well-worn stereotypes."
Top Chef Texas commercial
See more stories in:
Related stories
Faved or commented on by...
Related events
Latest Contests
Latest comments...
S&D Oyster in Uptown Dallas is remodeling
my first job was to was dishes, and change the grease trap, but ole herb.....he made it to where I w
Creepy rendering of Big Tex shows he's almost ready for the State Fair
gosh some honest feed back finally, I thought I was in Detroit, with such appathy these past few mon
Album review: Cas Haley runs with rhythm and soul on La Si Dah
And as we all know, Germans love David Hasselhof.
ksteubin, anonymous:
Vomit.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
pepper, anonymous:
"I live in New York but I can't think of the last time I visited the Statue of Liberty." Well...Padma...I live in Texas and I can't think of the last time I rode a horse, wore a g-d pair of cowboy boots, or wore a f'ing demin dress.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
cookingfresh, anonymous:
Being a fifth generation TEXAN, I wear boots, blue jeans, ride horses had a family farm. Worked on a small ranch and have a mighty nice cowboy hat collection but if you were to put me in a suit I might looks as uncomfortable as Tom does in boots and jeans.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
Teresa Gubbins, staff:
pepper, i'm with you, altho to be fair i think Padma was acknowledging that there's been stereotyping in all of the Top Chef seasons.
my main beef is that the producers came in with a set idea, and that involved dismissing the dining scene of any one Texas city. none of our cities were "big" enough to warrant their own season. that's one of those self-fulfilling things.
i guess we'll have to wait until Season 10 and see if it's going to be "Top Chef Oregon" or "Top Chef Washington State". because they need to keep outdoing themselves
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
damn yankee, anonymous:
You guys might find this interesting - China is limiting the number of reality shows on their television. Their reasons are shady - strengthening the government and trying to suppressing independent viewpoints - but I can't say I'd miss any reality shows if they disappeared. (At least, now that I don't watch The Amazing Race with my mom. :) )
http://www.boston.com/ae/tv/articles/...
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
Teresa Gubbins, staff:
the saving grace with reality shows is that they always shoot themselves in the foot by over-saturating over-packaging over-multiplying until whatever cachet the original idea had is long gone. i think top chef is right on the brink
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
Scott, anonymous:
The multi-city approach may have flowed, in part, from the incentives the State offered. Had a major Texas city been willing to offer the show better incentives, it might have ended up being a one-city season.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
wilsonbl5150, anonymous:
I plan on playing the Top Chef drinking game and I imagine I'll be hammered less than 30 minutes into the first episode.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
Sarah Blaskovich, staff:
I'm loving the drinking game idea. wilsonbl5150, while you're kicking 'em back, it would make our day if you would post an incoherent comment just to prove how very Texas the show will be!
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
OEsophagus, anonymous:
I've never met a television producer who had the capability to think for themselves.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
TLS, anonymous:
If they show tumbleweed or an armadillo crossing the road you have to chug the entire bottle of whatever you're drinking. Gold, Jerry, gold!
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
Nlh0730, anonymous:
I'm a Texan, and I'm not at all offended by the reference to the state instead of an individual city. First, to me it says that in other states there is only one city with a cuisine style so they mention only the city. Texas cities are so diverse, it's an opportunity to showcase it all. Tex-Mex is a perfect example - it changes within the state, more seafood driven in coastal areas, more chilies driven the closer you get to New Mexico, closer to traditional Mexican the closer to the borders, not to mention the barbecue influence of Texas and the Cajun influence of Louisiana. I have traveled and as far as I'm concerned, Texas as a whole has the best food in the world.
Link to this comment | Suggest removal
What do you think?