Joined Dec. 22, 2012
11 months, 2 weeks agoprometheus4us's comment on:
At the 1:53 mark Carly has a look of concern, which turns into a great smile when she notices the camera is on her. At 2:10 this concern seems to have deepened. Carly and Britney's remarks at the end are not sarcastic, because they are not bitter or meant to mock Rimes. Yet they both seem to say the opposite of how they felt. I think Carly was uncomfortable and Britney was shocked. So if they used a different tone, Carly's "You made me feel very comfortable" and Britney's "It was shockingly amazing" would have been sarcastic. Rimes poor performance did not help Carly. However, I feel the real reason Carly did not win was because XF had a 3-way finale where Carly and 5H split certain blocks of voters. In a 2 contestant finale, Carly would have likely won.